Introduction: A Slice for Everyone
When it comes to finding the best pizza in Reston or discovering the best pizza in Herndon, variety is the name of the game. From wood-fired Neapolitan pies to foldable New York–style slices, plus inventive fusion concepts that blend Indian spices or bold flavor combos—there’s a pizza for every palate here in Northern Virginia. Below, we’ll dive into each style, highlight standout spots, and give you the insider scoop so you can plan your next pizza night with confidence.
1. Traditional Italian & Neapolitan Gems
If you crave that authentic Italian flair—charred crust, fresh mozzarella, and a balanced tomato sauce—these restaurants deliver on taste and atmosphere.
Pupatella
- Known For: True Neapolitan-style pizza with San Marzano tomatoes, house-made mozzarella, and an airy, perfectly blistered crust.
- Try: Margherita or the Prosciutto & Arugula.
Crust Pizzeria Napoletana
- Location: Near Tysons (close enough for a short drive from Reston/Herndon).
- Known For: Wood-fired Neapolitan pies with a soft, chewy center and lightly charred edges.
Gregorio’s Trattoria
- Style: Italian-American comfort with New York–leaning crust, but they also serve classic Italian pastas.
- Family-Friendly: A welcoming atmosphere for larger groups or kids.
Piero’s Corner
- Atmosphere: Slightly upscale neighborhood restaurant in Herndon’s Franklin Farm area.
- Why Go: Traditional Italian menu, including hearty Sicilian pizzas and delicious pasta.
Lucia’s Italian Ristorante & Pizzeria
- Location: Technically in Herndon’s Fox Mill area.
- Known For: Family-owned vibe and robust Italian dishes paired with classic pizzas.
Deli Italiano
- Multiple Locations: Closest is often Great Falls, but easily reachable.
- Highlights: Italian-American menu with pizza, panini, subs, and pasta—reliable for delivery or casual dining.
North Italia
- Where: Reston Town Center.
- Why It’s Special: Modern, upscale spin on Italian fare; pizzas feature artisanal toppings like roasted mushrooms or truffles.
2. New York–Style & Fast-Casual Favorites
Thin, foldable crust with just the right sauce-to-cheese ratio—these are your spots for a classic New York slice or build-your-own convenience.
Santini’s
- Multiple Locations: Reston, Oakton, Sterling, etc.
- Highlights: NY-style slices, big subs, and plenty of seating for a quick bite.
&pizza
- Style: Fast-casual, personal pizzas made your way.
- Why Go: Unlimited toppings, vegan options, and lightning-fast prep.
Wiseguy Pizza
- Location: Reston Station area.
- Claim to Fame: Authentic NYC slices, perfect for a quick lunch or late-night craving.
Flippin’ Pizza
- Style: Classic, foldable NY-style slices.
- Where: Reston (South Lakes Dr) for carryout or dine-in.
Kook Dogg Café
- Location: 12100 Sunset Hills Rd R-6, Reston.
- Known For: Pizza & wings combos, plus inventive specialty pies.
Mr. Pepperoni
- What to Expect: Straightforward American pizzeria with budget-friendly deals.
- Perfect For: Takeout or delivery on busy nights.
Paisano’s Pizza
- Multiple Spots: Throughout Northern VA, including Herndon.
- Highlights: New York–inspired pies, subs, and fast delivery.
Vocelli Pizza
- Regional Chain: Reliable option for quick delivery and coupons.
- Style: Medium-thin crust, with a menu of subs and wings as well.
Ledo Pizza
- Unique Feature: Rectangular pies with a sweet sauce, polarizing but beloved by many longtime fans.
3. Fusion & Specialty Pizzas
Tired of the same old pepperoni? These spots infuse international flavors and creative toppings.
Pizza Twist (Chicago’s Pizza With a Twist)
- Location: Herndon’s Worldgate Dr.
- Style: Indian-fusion pizzas featuring butter chicken, paneer tikka, and tandoori-inspired toppings.
Mellow Mushroom
- Known For: Eccentric topping combos, creative names, and stone-baked crust.
- Try: Kosmic Karma (veggies + feta + pesto) or the Funky Q. Chicken.
Izzi at Aslin
- What’s Cool: Situated in Aslin Beer Co.’s Herndon taproom, known for craft brews + creative pies.
- Order: Seasonal specialty pizzas—often with hot honey, gourmet cheeses, or inventive veggie mixes.
4. Upscale & Sit-Down Experiences
When you want more than just a quick slice, check out these restaurants for refined menus and stylish ambiance.
Matchbox
- Location: Reston Town Center.
- Highlights: Wood-fired pies (try the Fire & Smoke), plus bistro classics and brunch.
Sixty Vines
- Why Go: A wine-centric concept with multiple wines on tap.
- Pizza: Thin-crust, gourmet toppings like prosciutto and goat cheese.
Cafesano
- Style: Mediterranean-inspired café with thin-crust pizzas, kabobs, salads.
- Atmosphere: Bright, casual setting—healthier spins on classic dishes.
5. Brewery Hangouts & Pairings
Craft beer fans, look here for pizza-and-pint pairings.
- Izzi at Aslin (mentioned above): Rotating beer list with specialty pizza.
- Mellow Mushroom: Offers craft brews on tap to match their fun, flavorful pies.
(Note: This section overlaps with Fusion & Specialty, but the vibe is all about the beer-pizza combo.)
6. Chain Pizza Afterthought
You’ll find all the big names around town. They may not top “best pizza” lists, but they’re familiar, quick, and often open late.
- Domino’s Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Papa John’s
- Pizza Boli’s (regional chain)
When speed, coupons, or late-night convenience is your main priority, these can do the trick.
Conclusion
Whether you’re on the hunt for the best pizza in Reston or exploring the best pizza in Herndon, this area offers something for every slice connoisseur. From authentic Neapolitan to bold Indian-fusion pies—and everything in between—you’ll never run out of new spots to try. Gather friends, pick a style (or two!), and enjoy the flavors each neighborhood has to offer.
Ready to plan your own Reston–Herndon pizza tour? Share this guide with friends, and let us know which pizzeria tops your list in the comments below. And if you need more recommendations or local insights, join our newsletter for exclusive updates about what’s happening in our area.
